Statement: Should the habit of being absent from the class-room be checked in educational institutions? Arguments: I. Yes. Otherwise it will create a poor image of the institute in the society. II. No. This will be an act of encroaching upon one's liberty.

if only argument I is strong
if only argument II is strong
if either I or II is strong
if neither I nor II is strong

Correct Answer: if neither I nor II is strong

Explanation:

Both I and II are weak argument. I portrays a trivial aspect, hence it is weak. II is weak because it advocates for one's liberty not in a rational sense.

← Previous Question Next Question→

More Questions from Statement and Argument

Statement: Should children be prevented completely form using the Internet? Arguments : I. No. Internet is a medium of education where children get education with entertainment. II. Yes. There are some sites available on Internet which show porno film or programmes etc, which affect the child's mind to a great extent; recent surveys have revealed most of the users of these sites are children.
Statement: Should there be a ban on the persons providing services to more than one firm or organisation? Arguments: I. Yes. It will reduce the problem of unemployment to some extent. II. No. It will create a lot of frustration and large amount of dissatisfaction and disappointment among the skillful and intellectual classes.
Statement: Should people be allowed to keep traditional arms while on a long train journey? Arguments: I. Yes. This will reduce the cases of train dacoities and other activities such as snatching chains or ornaments. II. No. This will create inconvenience to the passengers and aggravate the law and order situation.
Statement: Should there be a re-election in case the winner 's candidature is cancelled? Arguments: I. Yes, the winner represents the choice of the major portion of voters, and if his candidature is cancelled there must be a re-election to maintain the democratic ethos. II. No, it will be an injustice towards the person who stood second in the election.
Statement: Should there be a law in India to allow mutual transfer of convicts between India and other countries? Arguments: I. Yes, the move will help in giving appropriate punishment to the criminal according to the law of the country which has registered accusation against him. II. Yes, this will hinder the criminals form taking shelter in those countries from where they can't be entrusted to the police of that country where they have committed crime.
Statement: Should sex determination thought ultrasound and female fortitude be made a non- bailable offense? Arguments: I. Yes. It must be done instantly. II. No. Let people enjoy their right of freedom.
Statement: Should all the universities be allowed for educational FM radio? Arguments: I. No, the move will harm the outstanding objectives of the universities because the universities might tend to use the facility for commercial purposes. II. Yes, the move will reduce the gap of information between urban and rural areas. Besides, it will enable more people have access to education.
Statement: ''Each one teach one'' is the best policy to spread elementary education in India . Arguments: I. Yes, if 60% literate people teach 40% illiterates Indians then it seems quite possible. II. No, people have no time to spend for development of the society because naturally they are more keen to earn their livelihood .
Statement: Should the minimum age of 25 years for entry to bars and pubs be reduced? Arguments: I. Yes. A person is mature enough to differentiate between the good and the bad, the right and the wrong once he/she attains the age of 18-20 years, the age when one gets voting right . II. No. By this age, a person passes though various realities. It is usually after this age that one attains social maturity and economic independence. Reduction in this age limit would result in exposing the youth to risks owing to amateur decisions.
Statement: Should police pickets on road be not allowed to check luggages of travellers by stopping buses? Arguments: I. Yes. The move causes great inconvenience to travellers and contributes to some extent in causing traffic jams. II. No. The move will curtail the right of the police.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Join Discussion