Statement: Should fishery be banned during monsoon season? Argument: I. Yes, it is the time when fishes reproduce. II. No, the move will increase the prices of fishes enormously.

if only argument I is strong
if only argument II is strong
if either I or II is strong
if neither I nor II is strong

Correct Answer:

Explanation:

Banning for a short duration will be beneficial in the long run because reproduction will increase the gross quantity of the fishes. Hence, argument I is strong . Argument II is also strong because increase in the price of fishes will cause inconvenience to the common people.

← Previous Question Next Question→

More Questions from Statement and Argument

Statement: Should cricket be made a national game for India, replacing hockey? Arguments: I. Yes, our performance in hockey, both at national and international levels, is very dismal in comparison with cricket. II. Yes, recognition of cricket and cricket players is more than hockey and hockey players.
Statement: Should National Human Rights commission be armed with penal powers? Arguments: I. Yes, it is the only way to restrict the violation of human rights which is increasing at a fast pace. II. No, if this happens people will prefer to keep distance from human rights activists and will not cooperate with them because of the fear of red-tapism of law.
Statement: Should Indian restart bus service between India and the neighboring country, which is supposed to be the epicenter of cross- border terrorism in Indian? Arguments: I. Yes, it will increase the scope of getting better health services, quality products, and doing good business, besides easing tension between the two countries, and give impetus to mutual harmony. II. No, it will be used for smuggling of fake currency, spurious drugs, sophisticated arms etc.
Statement: Should Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes candidates who have failed to secure the qualifying marks of 40 per cent in the MBBS examination be selected for reserved seats in medicine? Arguments: I. Yes, reserved seats of the categories must be filled with the students of the respective categories to fulfil the constitutional norms. II. No, this will harm the purpose of qualifying marks.
Statement: Should the sole evidence of a rape victim be supposed enough to prove the guilt? Arguments: I. Yes, rape is a heinous offence. II. No, the move will increase the chances of conviction of innocent persons.
Statement: Should funds for social justice and empowerment be released to the NGOs by Central government if state machinery fails to make requisition to the ministry concerned of the Central government? Arguments: I. Yes, Various NGOs have a strong base among the people and experience of utilising funds issued by the Central government though the state government. II. No, the ministry will not be able to ascertain the works of the NGOs and will face practical problems.
Statement: Should the Centre consult the government of a state before deploying the army in its territory for the maintenance of law and order? Arguments: I. Yes, if the state government is taken into confidence, the purpose of deploying the army will be more meaningful. II. No, the Centre occupies position above the states and enjoys more power than the states.
Statement: Should India make it compulsory to sterilise every woman going for second delivery? Arguments: I. Yes, this is the only way to reduce the growth rate of population at faster pace. II. No, it will be a cruel act against nature.
Statement: Should the Indian Railways be corporatised? Arguments: I. Yes, the move will make it an autonomous entity, which will bring in enormous changes like quick decision-making . II. No, it is futile unless we put an end to the handling of archaic rules in the appointment of favourites to the top positions.
Statement: Should there be a law against superstition in India? Arguments: I. Yes, it is a belief in magical and similar influences, in idea or practice based on this. II. No, it has been recognised by our forefathers and has a strong base in our society.

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Join Discussion