English grammar error-spotting (sequence of tenses in reported conditionals): Identify the erroneous part among A–C in the sentence below (select ‘‘No error.’’ only if all parts are correct). Pay particular attention to backshift after a past reporting verb and the modal choice ‘‘will’’ vs ‘‘would’’: ‘‘He said that he / will mind if / I refused his offer. / No error.’’
-
AHe said that he
-
Bwill mind if
-
CI refused his offer.
-
DNo error.
Answer
Correct Answer: will mind if
Explanation
Given data
- Part A: ‘‘He said that he’’ (past reporting verb ‘‘said’’)
- Part B: ‘‘will mind if’’
- Part C: ‘‘I refused his offer.’’
- Part D: ‘‘No error.’’
Concept / ApproachIn reported speech with a past reporting verb (‘‘said’’), verbs in subordinate clauses normally backshift to express future-in-the-past. Therefore, ‘‘will’’ in the subordinate clause typically changes to ‘‘would’’ when the perspective is retained in indirect speech.
Step-by-step evaluationStep 1: Identify the reporting verb—‘‘said’’ (past tense) → triggers backshift.Step 2: Replace future modal relative to past viewpoint—‘‘will’’ → ‘‘would’’ (future-in-the-past).Step 3: Check the ‘‘if’’-clause—‘‘if I refused his offer’’ is acceptable as the hypothetical/contingent condition set at that past time.
Verification / Alternative (corrected version)Correct: ‘‘He said that he would mind if I refused his offer.’’(Here, ‘‘would mind’’ correctly reflects the future-in-the-past viewpoint established by ‘‘said’’.)
Common pitfalls
- Leaving ‘‘will’’ unchanged after a past reporting verb in indirect speech.
- Changing ‘‘refused’’ unnecessarily; it already matches the past-time reference of the reported condition.
Final Answerwill mind if