Plasticity Chart – Local “family” of soils in a restricted area For soils with common geological origin from one locality, their LL–PI values usually plot as:
-
AA zone above the A-line (scattered region)
-
BA straight line roughly parallel to the A-line
-
CA straight line perpendicular to the A-line
-
DAnywhere on the chart without pattern
Answer
Correct Answer: A straight line roughly parallel to the A-line
Explanation
Introduction / Context:On the plasticity chart (PI vs LL), soils from a single geological formation often share mineralogy and particle characteristics. Consequently, their Atterberg data tend to align along a “local line.”
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Soils sampled within a restricted geographic area and common origin.
- Atterberg limits tested consistently.
Concept / Approach:
Casagrande's plasticity chart distinguishes clays and silts using the A-line. Local families of soils often fall along a straight trend roughly parallel to the A-line, reflecting consistent clay mineral proportions and activity.
Step-by-Step Solution:
1) Plot LL on x-axis and PI on y-axis for the soil set.2) Observe clustering → trend approximates a straight line.3) Slope similar to A-line indicates mineralogical similarity within the family.Verification / Alternative check:
Many site datasets show tight linear bands; departures often indicate contamination, different depositional histories, or testing inconsistencies.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
(a) Describes a region, not a line; (c) perpendicular trend lacks basis; (d) ignores the observed geological consistency.
Common Pitfalls:
Mixing samples from unrelated formations or misclassifying by not checking the A-line offset (clay vs silt).
Final Answer:
A straight line roughly parallel to the A-line