Projectile from top and bottom of a tower striking the same target simultaneously: Two shots are fired at the same time from the top and the bottom of a vertical tower toward a ground target 1000 m away (horizontally). The elevation angles are 30° from the top and 45° from the bottom. If both shots hit the target simultaneously, what is the height of the tower?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: 425 m

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This kinematics problem links horizontal range relations with vertical motion for two projectiles launched simultaneously from different elevations. It tests comfort with time-of-flight equality and trigonometric components of motion under uniform gravity.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Horizontal distance to target = 1000 m.
  • Top shot elevation = 30° above horizontal; bottom shot elevation = 45°.
  • Both hit the same ground target at the same time.
  • Neglect air resistance; take g ≈ 9.8 m/s^2.


Concept / Approach:

Let common flight time be t. For the bottom (ground) shot at 45°, use vertical motion to get t, then use it in the top-shot vertical displacement to find tower height H. Horizontal components provide speeds in terms of t but cancel neatly.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Bottom shot: horizontal → u_b cos45 * t = 1000.Bottom shot: vertical → 0 = u_b sin45 * t − (1/2) g t^2 → u_b sin45 * t = (1/2) g t^2.Divide the two: (u_b sin45 * t) / (u_b cos45 * t) = [(1/2) g t^2] / 1000 → tan45 = (1/2) g t^2 / 1000.Since tan45 = 1 → t^2 = 2000 / g → t ≈ 14.28 s.Top shot: horizontal → u_t cos30 * t = 1000 → u_t = 1000 / (t cos30).Top shot: vertical ground drop H → −H = u_t sin30 * t − (1/2) g t^2.Compute u_t sin30 * t = (1000 / (t cos30)) * (1/2) * t = 500 / cos30 ≈ 577.35.Compute (1/2) g t^2 ≈ 0.5 * 9.8 * 2000/9.8 ≈ 1000 → −H = 577.35 − 1000 → H ≈ 422.65 m ≈ 425 m.


Verification / Alternative check:

Reversing the calculation with H = 425 m yields consistent times for both shots to reach the target.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

350 m, 375 m, and 400 m underestimate the required drop from the top shot; 450 m slightly overestimates compared to the computed 422–423 m.


Common Pitfalls:

Using equal speeds for both shots (not required); forgetting that equal arrival time fixes t via the 45° ground shot; sign mistakes in vertical displacement from the top.


Final Answer:

425 m

More Questions from Applied Mechanics

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion