Force systems — can two equal and opposite parallel forces with distinct lines of action be replaced by a single force?
-
ACorrect
-
BIncorrect
-
CCorrect only if the lines of action intersect
-
DCorrect if their magnitudes are unequal
-
ECorrect, but only in 3D
Answer
Correct Answer: Incorrect
Explanation
Introduction / Context:This question probes the concept of a couple in engineering mechanics. Two equal and opposite parallel forces whose lines of action are separated form a pure moment (a couple), not a single resultant force.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Two forces, equal in magnitude and opposite in direction.
- Forces are parallel, with a finite perpendicular distance between their lines of action.
- Rigid body assumption.
Concept / Approach:When two equal and opposite parallel forces are separated by a distance, their net force is zero, but they create a nonzero moment. This moment is called a couple, with magnitude M = F * d, where F is the magnitude of either force and d is the perpendicular distance between their lines of action.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Compute net force: F_net = +F + (−F) = 0.Compute moment: M = F * d about any point (independent of reference point for a couple).Interpretation: The system reduces to a pure couple, not a single force.Hence, the statement claiming replacement by a single force is incorrect.Verification / Alternative check:Try to represent a couple by a single force at any point; you will always introduce an unintended net force, which contradicts the original zero-resultant condition. Only a free vector couple correctly represents the system.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Correct / variants: Misrepresent the mechanics; a single force cannot replicate a pure couple.
- Lines of action intersect: They are parallel; if they intersected, the system would be concurrent, not a couple.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing a couple with two non-parallel forces; believing every force system reduces to a single force plus a moment at the same point (here the net force is strictly zero).
Final Answer:Incorrect