In what time would a cistern be filled by three pipes whose diameters are $1\text{ cm}$, $1\frac{1}{3}\text{ cm}$ and $2\text{ cm}$ running together, when the largest alone will fill it in $61$ minutes, the amount of water flowing in by each pipe, being proportional to the square of its diameter? (Railways, 2006)
Aptitude
Pipes and Cistern
Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
-
A$25$ minutes
-
B$30$ minutes
-
C$36$ minutes
-
D$40$ minutes
Answer
Correct Answer: $36$ minutes
Explanation
### Concept & Flow Rate Proportionality
When the amount of water flowing through a pipe is directly proportional to the square of its diameter, the efficiency (rate of work) of each pipe can be represented by $d^2$.
$$ \text{Efficiency} \propto \text{Diameter}^2 $$
The total capacity of the cistern can be found by multiplying the efficiency of a single pipe by the time it takes to fill the cistern alone.
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **Find Efficiencies:**
The given diameters are $1\text{ cm}$, $1\frac{1}{3}\text{ cm}$ (which is $\frac{4}{3}\text{ cm}$), and $2\text{ cm}$.
Let their efficiencies be $E_1$, $E_2$, and $E_3$.
$E_1 \propto 1^2 = 1$
$E_2 \propto (\frac{4}{3})^2 = \frac{16}{9}$
$E_3 \propto 2^2 = 4$
* **Calculate Total Capacity:**
The largest pipe (diameter $2\text{ cm}$, efficiency $4$) takes $61$ minutes.
Total Work (Capacity) $= \text{Efficiency} \times \text{Time} = 4 \times 61 = 244$ units.
* **Calculate Combined Efficiency:**
Sum of efficiencies $= 1 + \frac{16}{9} + 4 = 5 + \frac{16}{9} = \frac{45 + 16}{9} = \frac{61}{9}$ units per minute.
* **Calculate Total Time:**
Time taken by all three together $= \frac{\text{Total Capacity}}{\text{Combined Efficiency}}$
$= \frac{244}{\frac{61}{9}} = 244 \times \frac{9}{61} = 4 \times 9 = 36$ minutes.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
By identifying the rates as $1$, $\frac{16}{9}$, and $4$, you immediately see the sum is $\frac{61}{9}$. Because the largest pipe takes $61$ minutes, the math is perfectly rigged to cancel out the $61$ in the numerator and denominator, leaving $4 \times 9 = 36$ as a rapid mental calculation.
### Common Pitfall
A common mistake is assuming the flow rate is directly proportional to the diameter rather than the square of the diameter, leading to incorrect efficiency ratios like $1 : \frac{4}{3} : 2$. Always read the proportionality condition carefully.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **$36$ minutes**.