Introduction / Context:
This puzzle is a poetic riddle that describes an ordinary object in an unusual way. The lines "Tear one off and scratch my head, what once was red is black instead" invite you to visualise an action and notice a colour change. Such riddles test your ability to connect everyday experiences with metaphorical language. The challenge is to identify which common item behaves exactly as described when used in the normal way.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- We are dealing with a small, everyday object that you can hold and use with your hands.
- "Tear one off" suggests removing a single item from a group or strip.
- "Scratch my head" indicates striking or rubbing one end, the "head", against a rough surface.
- "What once was red is black instead" clearly refers to a noticeable change of colour from red to black.
- The options are: A matchstick, A pencil, A candle, and An eraser.
Concept / Approach:
The main idea is to connect each part of the riddle to how the object is actually used. With a book of matches, you tear off a single matchstick from the pad. The tip of the match is often red or reddish brown. When you strike or "scratch" that head against the rough striking surface, it ignites. After burning, the head and top part of the match become blackened and charred. This sequence perfectly matches the lines of the riddle. The other options do not involve tearing off individual pieces in this way, nor do they reliably change from red to black when used correctly.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Interpret "tear one off" as removing one small item from a larger connected set, like a match from a matchbook.
Step 2: Interpret "scratch my head" as striking the head of the object against a rough surface, similar to lighting a match.
Step 3: Consider that many safety match heads are red or reddish before ignition.
Step 4: When a match is lit and then burns out, the head and tip of the stick become black and charred.
Step 5: Check the other items: pencils do not normally start red and turn black just by scratching, candles are not torn off in single pieces and scraped at the head in that way, and erasers show wear but not this specific red to black transformation.
Step 6: Conclude that a matchstick is the only object that clearly fits every part of the description.
Verification / Alternative check:
To verify, picture a small matchbook: you physically tear out a match, striking its red head on the rough strip to light it. Once burned, the flame leaves behind a black, ashy tip. The image of "what once was red is black instead" becomes very vivid. Pencils, candles, and erasers can get dirty or darkened with use, but they are not usually red at the tip turning black through a single "scratch" action. This confirms that the riddle was written with a matchstick in mind.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
A pencil can have a coloured coating, but you do not usually "tear one off" from a group. You also do not strike its head to transform a red tip to black; instead, you sharpen it. A candle may burn and darken at the wick, but you do not tear a candle off from a strip, and the wick is not typically bright red. An eraser can be rubbed and may appear dirty, yet the specific red to black change and the tearing motion do not match. Only the matchstick satisfies all clues simultaneously.
Common Pitfalls:
One common pitfall is to read "scratch my head" and immediately think of human head scratching or scalp irritation instead of a physical object. Another mistake is focusing solely on colour change or only on tearing, not on both hints working together. Good riddle solving requires combining all details: the action of tearing, the striking or scratching motion, and the red to black colour change. When these are considered together, the answer becomes very clear.
Final Answer:
The object described by the lines "Tear one off and scratch my head, what once was red is black instead" is
A matchstick.
Discussion & Comments