More Questions from Statement and Assumption

Statement–Assumption — “If there were posters available of these top IT professionals, they would have replaced Shahrukh and Sachin on many hostel walls by now.” Assumptions: I. Posters of IT professionals are not currently available in the market. II. Top IT professionals are so popular among students that their posters would displace film and sports icons.

Verbal Reasoning Statement and Assumption Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
  • A
    if only assumption I is implicit.
  • B
    if only assumption II is implicit.
  • C
    if either I or II is implicit.
  • D
    if neither I nor II is implicit.
  • E
    if both I and II is implicit.

Answer

Correct Answer: if both I and II is implicit.

Explanation

Introduction / Context:The sentence uses a counterfactual: if posters of certain IT stars existed, they would have replaced celebrity posters on hostel walls. We need to identify the hidden beliefs that make this claim reasonable.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • “If there were posters available …” suggests such posters are presently unavailable.
  • The claim predicts replacement—i.e., IT icons’ appeal would surpass existing film/sports icons among students.

Concept / Approach:For a counterfactual of this kind, two things must be true: (a) the missing condition (availability) is what prevents the outcome at present, and (b) the outcome (replacement) would indeed occur given availability, which rests on presumed popularity or aspirational pull.

Step-by-Step Solution:1) Assumption I: The “if there were” framing ordinarily implies non-availability now; otherwise, availability would not be the barrier. Hence I is implicit.2) Assumption II: Predicting “replacement” requires believing student demand for these posters is strong enough to displace major celebrities. Therefore II is also implicit.

Verification / Alternative check:Without (I), the counterfactual loses force; without (II), replacement would be an overreach. Both are needed.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:Only-I/Only-II/Either/Neither each omits part of the logic behind the forecasted displacement.

Common Pitfalls:Treating “if available” as a mere wish rather than the stated binding constraint, or ignoring the popularity premise required for replacement.

Final Answer:if both I and II is implicit.

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion