Sizing a crossing from spread: If the spread between the point and the splice rails is 50 cm at a distance of 4.25 m from the theoretical point, what is the size of the crossing (expressed as 1 in N)?
-
A1 in 6
-
B1 in 8.5
-
C1 in 12
-
D1 in 16
-
E1 in 10
Answer
Correct Answer: 1 in 8.5
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Crossing size on railways is often denoted as 1 in N, where N equals cotangent of the crossing angle. In field practice, N can be computed from the measured spread (divergence) over a known distance from the theoretical point.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Spread between point and splice rails = 50 cm = 0.50 m.
- Distance from theoretical point = 4.25 m.
- Standard geometric relation for small angles: tanθ ≈ spread / distance.
Concept / Approach:Crossing number N = 1 / tanθ = distance / spread (for the standard measurement line). Thus, knowing spread and distance directly yields N.
Step-by-Step Solution:Compute tanθ = 0.50 / 4.25 = 0.11765 (approx.).Find N = 1 / tanθ = 4.25 / 0.50 = 8.5.Crossing size = 1 in 8.5.
Verification / Alternative check:Typical standard sizes include 1 in 8.5, 1 in 12, 1 in 16, etc. The computed N matches a common standard, confirming plausibility.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 1 in 6: Too sharp; N should be 8.5 from the measurement.
- 1 in 12 / 1 in 16: Too flat compared to calculated value.
- 1 in 10: Close but not equal to the computed 8.5, hence incorrect.
Common Pitfalls:Mixing units (cm vs m); using chord length instead of the prescribed distance; rounding N to a different standard without checking the given data.
Final Answer:1 in 8.5