Compressible fluids – variability of specific weight “The specific weight of compressible fluids does not remain constant.” Is this statement:
-
ATrue
-
BFalse
-
CTrue only at very high pressure
-
DTrue only at cryogenic temperatures
-
EFalse; specific weight is fixed by g
Answer
Correct Answer: True
Explanation
Introduction:Unlike liquids (often approximated as incompressible), gases are compressible and their density varies significantly with pressure and temperature. This affects specific weight, which depends directly on density.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Specific weight γ = ρ * g.
- Compressible fluid: ρ is a function of p and T.
- Gravity g is approximately constant for terrestrial applications.
Concept / Approach:Because γ is proportional to ρ, any change in ρ due to compression/expansion or heating/cooling changes γ. For gases obeying the ideal-gas relation, ρ = p / (R * T), so γ varies with p and T even at modest ranges.
Step-by-Step Solution:1) Write γ = ρ * g.2) For a gas, substitute ρ from its equation of state (e.g., ideal gas).3) Observe that p↑ or T↓ increases ρ and thus γ; p↓ or T↑ decreases γ.4) Therefore γ is not constant for compressible fluids.
Verification / Alternative check:Atmospheric γ decreases with altitude as p and ρ drop; engineering tables list air density and weight density at different T and p.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- False statements ignore the p–T dependence of ρ.
- Restricting to “very high pressure” or “cryogenic” is unnecessary; variability exists over wide conditions.
- g alone does not fix γ without ρ.
Common Pitfalls:Applying an incompressible approximation to gases outside narrow ranges.
Final Answer:True