In continuous distillation design, the Souders–Brown equation (for maximum allowable vapor velocity to avoid entrainment) is primarily used to estimate the required diameter of the column based on flooding considerations. What does it directly help you calculate for sizing?

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Diameter of the distillation column (capacity at allowable vapor velocity)

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
The Souders–Brown equation is a classic capacity relationship used in vapor–liquid contacting equipment such as distillation columns, absorbers, and vapor–liquid separators. It sets an upper limit on superficial vapor velocity to prevent liquid entrainment and flooding. Designers use this limit to select an economical column diameter that carries the specified vapor flow safely below flooding.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Steady-state continuous distillation column.
  • Known vapor and liquid rates and physical properties (density-based K-value usage).
  • Acceptable design fraction of flooding (for example 70–85%).


Concept / Approach:
The standard form gives a maximum allowable superficial vapor velocity v_allow based on a K-value and the density difference between liquid and vapor. Once v_allow is known, the cross-sectional area A needed for the specified vapor volumetric rate Q_v is A = Q_v / v_allow. From A, the column internal diameter follows by D = sqrt(4A / π).


Step-by-Step Solution:
Use Souders–Brown to compute v_allow from fluid densities and service K.Compute cross-sectional area: A = Q_v / v_allow.Convert area to diameter: D = sqrt(4A / π).Apply a design fraction of flooding (capacity margin) to finalize D.


Verification / Alternative check:
Compare resulting diameter with vendor correlations or rate-based hydraulics. Check that tray pressure drop, weir loading, and downcomer backup are acceptable at the chosen D.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Tray pressure drop: determined by tray hydraulics, not directly by Souders–Brown.Downcomer residence time: set by hydraulics/layout, not the S–B velocity limit.Number of stages: dictated by mass-transfer/thermodynamics (McCabe–Thiele or rate-based), not S–B.Weir height: a tray hardware variable, not derived from S–B.


Common Pitfalls:
Using a generic K without checking service (foaming/corrosive/dirty).Sizing exactly at flooding without a margin.Ignoring liquid handling (downcomer backup) after picking diameter.


Final Answer:
Diameter of the distillation column (capacity at allowable vapor velocity)

More Questions from Process Equipment and Plant Design

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion