Open-channel hydraulics (trapezoidal weirs): In a standard Cipolletti weir used for discharge measurement, what side slope is generally provided on each sloping face (horizontal : vertical)?
-
A1 : 5
-
B1 : 4
-
C1 : 3
-
D1 : 2
-
E1 : 1
Answer
Correct Answer: 1 : 4
Explanation
Introduction / Context:
A Cipolletti weir is a trapezoidal sharp-crested weir commonly used in irrigation and water-resources engineering to measure open-channel discharge. It is designed so that the contraction errors on the sides self-compensate, allowing a simple head–discharge relationship without side-contraction corrections.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Weir is sharp-crested with trapezoidal opening.
- Standard Cipolletti proportioning is used for practical field measurements.
- Side slope is expressed as horizontal : vertical (H:V).
- Free overfall (ventilated nappe) conditions are assumed for correct calibration.
Concept / Approach:
For a trapezoidal weir, the side contractions reduce the effective width compared to a rectangular weir. Cipolletti specified a particular side slope that compensates for these side contractions so that the discharge formula resembles that of a rectangular weir without separate correction factors. The chosen slope balances geometry and hydraulics across typical heads.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recall the standard: Cipolletti weir side slopes are 1 horizontal to 4 vertical on each side.Interpretation: for every 1 unit of horizontal run, the face rises 4 units vertically.This geometry yields a discharge relation that inherently accounts for side contraction.Verification / Alternative check:
Textbook tables and field handbooks consistently cite 1:4 (H:V) as the Cipolletti slope; other slopes correspond to nonstandard trapezoidal weirs requiring separate calibration.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 1:5, 1:3, 1:2, and 1:1 do not deliver the intended automatic compensation and are not the standard Cipolletti geometry.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing the notation (some authors write V:H; here the question uses H:V, i.e., 1:4).
- Applying side-slope data to suppressed rectangular weirs (which have vertical sides).
Final Answer:
1 : 4