Great-circle navigation: the shortest surface distance between two locations on the Earth is equal to which of the following?
-
Alength of the equator between their longitudes
-
Blength of the parallel between their longitudes
-
Clength of the arc of the great circle passing through them
-
Dnone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: length of the arc of the great circle passing through them
Explanation
Introduction / Context:In geodesy, navigation, and aviation, the shortest route over the Earth’s surface is fundamental for route planning and distance computation. On a sphere (or near-spherical ellipsoid), this path is the great-circle arc between the two points.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- The Earth is approximated as a sphere for conceptual understanding (ellipsoidal refinements are small for many purposes).
- Two points (not antipodal) define a unique great circle.
- We compare distances along equator, parallels, and great circles.
Concept / Approach:A great circle is any circle on the sphere whose center coincides with the sphere’s center. The geodesic (shortest surface path) between two points on a sphere lies along the great-circle arc joining them. Parallels (except the equator) are small circles and do not provide shortest paths unless the two points happen to lie on the equator itself.
Step-by-Step Solution:Construct the unique great circle through the two points (and the center of the sphere).Measure the central angle Δσ between their position vectors.Surface distance = R * Δσ, which follows the great-circle arc.
Verification / Alternative check:Airline ‘‘orthodrome’’ routes appear curved on Mercator projections but are shortest because they follow great circles. Rhumb lines (loxodromes) are longer except in special cases.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Equator segment is a great-circle arc only if both points lie on the equator.
- Parallels are small circles and generally longer than the great-circle route.
- ‘‘None of these’’ is incorrect since the great-circle arc is the standard result.
Common Pitfalls:
- Misinterpreting map projection curves as physical path lengths.
- Confusing loxodromic (constant bearing) with geodesic (shortest) routes.
Final Answer:length of the arc of the great circle passing through them