Settling under Stokes’ regime: For a spherical particle of diameter d < 0.1 mm settling in a fluid, which expression gives the terminal settling velocity according to Stokes’ law?
-
Av_s = [ g * (Gs − 1) * d^2 ] / (18 * nu)
-
Bv_s = [ 18 * nu ] / [ g * (Gs − 1) * d^2 ]
-
Cv_s = [ g * (Gs − 1) * d ] / (18 * nu)
-
Dv_s = [ g * (Gs − 1) * d^3 ] / (18 * nu)
Answer
Correct Answer: v_s = [ g * (Gs − 1) * d^2 ] / (18 * nu)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Primary sedimentation and grit removal design rely on predicting particle settling velocities. For very small spherical particles at low Reynolds number (laminar regime), Stokes’ law provides a simple analytical expression relating size, fluid properties, and density contrast to settling velocity.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Spherical particle with diameter d < 0.1 mm (small enough for laminar settling).
- Specific gravity of particle = Gs; fluid kinematic viscosity = nu.
- Flow conditions satisfy Stokes’ regime (Re <≈ 1).
Concept / Approach:
Stokes’ law (laminar settling) states the drag force equals weight minus buoyancy at terminal velocity. Solving the force balance yields v_s proportional to d^2 and inversely proportional to viscosity. The density term appears as (Gs − 1) because buoyancy subtracts the fluid density from particle density.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Write force balance at terminal velocity: drag = submerged weight.Drag (sphere) = 3 * pi * mu * d * v_s; convert mu to nu using mu = rho * nu.Submerged weight = (pi/6) * d^3 * (rho_s − rho) * g.Solve for v_s to obtain v_s = [ g * (Gs − 1) * d^2 ] / (18 * nu).Verification / Alternative check:
Dimensional check: numerator has L/T^2 * L^2 = L^3/T^2; denominator has L^2/T; result is L/T (velocity), consistent.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option (b) inverts the relation; (c) uses d^1 not d^2; (d) uses d^3, which applies to buoyant weight but not to velocity form.
Common Pitfalls:
Applying Stokes’ law beyond its Re limit; using kinematic vs dynamic viscosity inconsistently; neglecting flocculation that changes effective particle size and density.
Final Answer:
v_s = [ g * (Gs − 1) * d^2 ] / (18 * nu)