In this sentence improvement question, choose the alternative that makes the bracketed part grammatically and idiomatically correct. The sentence is: "She and Dad would (has had loved) Amit." Which option best improves the bracketed verb phrase?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: have loved

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This question tests your understanding of verb forms and auxiliary verbs in English, especially in conditional or hypothetical constructions. The sentence She and Dad would has had loved Amit is clearly incorrect as written, and you must choose the form that correctly follows would when referring to a completed action in the past. Sentence improvement questions like this are very common in banking and SSC exams and require familiarity with standard English patterns rather than literal translation from regional languages.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • The complete sentence is: She and Dad would (has had loved) Amit.
  • The subject is compound: She and Dad, which is plural.
  • The modal auxiliary is would, which can be followed by base verb or by have plus past participle for past conditionals.
  • The options are has loved, have loved, to loved and no improvement.


Concept / Approach:
In standard English, would have plus past participle is used to express a past hypothetical or unfulfilled action. For a plural subject like She and Dad, the correct form is would have loved, not would has loved. The sequence has had loved in the original bracketed phrase is incorrect because it combines present perfect and past perfect elements in a way that does not fit after would. When improving such sentences, you must look for the auxiliary have after would, then attach the past participle of the main verb, here loved.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify the structure needed with the modal would. For an unreal or hypothetical past action, English uses would have plus past participle. Step 2: Recognise that the main verb is love and its past participle is loved. Step 3: Combine them to form would have loved for any subject, singular or plural. Step 4: Look at option B: have loved. If we substitute, we get She and Dad would have loved Amit, which matches the correct pattern. Step 5: Check other options: has loved conflicts with the auxiliary would, to loved is ungrammatical because would to loved is not a valid sequence, and no improvement retains the clearly wrong phrase has had loved. Therefore, option B is the correct improvement.


Verification / Alternative check:
You can compare with similar sentences: He would have liked the food if it had been less spicy, or They would have helped if they had known. In each case, would have plus past participle expresses a past action that did not actually happen but is imagined. Applying the same pattern, She and Dad would have loved Amit expresses a hypothetical affection, perhaps if certain conditions had been met. This confirms that have loved is the correct form after would for this sentence.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Has loved uses has, which is present perfect auxiliary, and does not follow would in standard English; we do not say would has loved. To loved is incorrect because to must be followed by the base form love, not the past participle loved. No improvement would leave the phrase has had loved in place, which is doubly wrong: has had is a confusing mixture of present and past perfect auxiliaries and cannot be joined with would in this context. None of these forms fit correct conditional grammar, so they must be rejected.


Common Pitfalls:
Many learners struggle with modal auxiliaries plus perfect aspect, especially when translating from their first language. A common error is to mix has or had randomly with would, resulting in forms like would has or would had without the necessary have. Another pitfall is not recognising that She and Dad functions as a plural subject, which could mislead some students into thinking has is required. The safest strategy is to remember the fixed pattern would have plus past participle for unreal past situations and apply it consistently in such questions.


Final Answer:
The improved sentence is She and Dad would have loved Amit, so the correct choice is have loved.

More Questions from English

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion