Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: have decided
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This question tests your understanding of tense consistency in reported speech and explanations of decisions. When describing a decision that has already been made and still has relevance at the present moment, English commonly uses the present perfect tense have decided. Combining this correctly with the present tense ask is important for natural sounding English.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Original sentence: People ask me why I decide to start a new magazine.
- Underlined verb phrase: I decide.
- Options: will decide, am deciding, have decided, No improvement.
- The intended meaning is that people ask about a decision that has already been taken.
Concept / Approach:
The verb ask is in the simple present, indicating a general or repeated action in the present. The decision to start a new magazine is a completed action whose effects continue in the present. For such a past decision with present relevance, English prefers the present perfect have decided. The simple present decide suggests a habit or repeated action, which does not fit the context of one specific decision.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify that people ask me is in the present simple, meaning they ask now or repeatedly.
Step 2: Interpret the clause why I decide to start a new magazine. It refers to a particular decision already made.
Step 3: Recognise that the correct tense for such a decision is present perfect: I have decided.
Step 4: Replace decide with have decided to obtain why I have decided to start a new magazine.
Step 5: Check other options:
- Will decide suggests a future decision, not one already taken.
- Am deciding suggests the process is still going on, which does not match the idea of having started a new magazine.
- No improvement would keep an unnatural use of simple present.
Verification / Alternative check:
Think of typical explanations: People often ask me why I have decided to move abroad. Here, have decided clearly indicates a decision recently made that people are reacting to now. If we used decide, it would suggest that the speaker is making this decision repeatedly, which would be illogical. By the same reasoning, have decided is the correct tense for the magazine example.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Will decide in option A indicates a future decision, which does not fit the description of people already asking about it.
Am deciding in option B describes an ongoing process, implying the decision has not been finalised, which contradicts the idea of starting a new magazine.
No improvement in option D is not acceptable because the simple present decide is not the natural tense here.
Common Pitfalls:
Learners sometimes overuse the simple present when they see another present tense in the sentence. They may think that present plus present always agrees. However, English often uses present perfect to talk about past actions with present effects. To avoid mistakes, pay attention to whether the action is completed and whether people are reacting to its result now.
Final Answer:
The correct improvement is have decided, giving People ask me why I have decided to start a new magazine.
Discussion & Comments