Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: 2
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
Error spotting questions often focus on correct use of prepositions, especially with words like between and among. English distinguishes between relationships involving two clearly defined groups and those involving more than two entities. Using the wrong preposition can make a sentence sound incorrect, even if the rest of the grammar is fine.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Full sentence: Several great battles took place among the British and the Americans.
- Part (1): Several great battles.
- Part (2): took place among.
- Part (3): the British and the Americans.
- Part (4): No Error.
Concept / Approach:
In standard English, between is used when we are talking about two people, groups, or things. Among is used when referring to more than two or to an undefined group. Since the sentence mentions exactly two parties, the British and the Americans, the correct preposition is between, not among. Therefore, the error lies in the part containing among.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify the two sides involved in the battles: the British and the Americans.
Step 2: Recall the rule: between is used with two distinct parties, among with more than two.
Step 3: Replace among with between to get Several great battles took place between the British and the Americans.
Step 4: Check each part for additional errors:
- Several great battles is correctly formed.
- Took place is an appropriate verb phrase for events happening.
- The British and the Americans correctly names the two groups.
Step 5: Conclude that only part (2), containing among, is incorrect.
Verification / Alternative check:
Compare with examples: The agreement was signed between the company and the union or There was a dispute between the two neighbours. In both cases, between is used because only two parties are involved. We would use among in sentences like There was much discussion among the members of the committee, where more than two participants are implied. This comparison confirms that between is required in the battle sentence.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Part (1) Several great battles correctly uses plural form and adjective.
Part (3) the British and the Americans is grammatically and semantically correct.
Part (4) No Error is wrong because we have identified an error in part (2).
Common Pitfalls:
Some learners believe that between is only for two individuals, not for two groups or nations, and may therefore choose among out of habit. Others think between is informal and among more formal. In fact, the rule applies to the number of parties, regardless of whether they are individuals or groups. Remember: two parties, use between; more than two, generally use among.
Final Answer:
The error is in part (2); among should be replaced by between.
Discussion & Comments