Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: not the triumph but the breakdown
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This sentence improvement question examines parallelism and article usage in English. The sentence is We are withnessing not triumph but the breakdown of democracy, with not triumph but the breakdown underlined. Ignoring the spelling mistake in withnessing (which should be witnessing), the test focuses on whether the two contrasted nouns triumph and breakdown are treated in a grammatically parallel way. Article usage can make the structure more balanced and formal.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
In English, when we contrast two parallel ideas with not...but..., we often use similar structures on both sides. The phrase not triumph but the breakdown is slightly unbalanced because triumph appears without an article, while the breakdown has one. A more symmetrical form is not the triumph but the breakdown, where both nouns take the article the. This structure emphasises that what we are witnessing is not the expected triumph of democracy, but rather its breakdown.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Verification / Alternative check:
Read the improved sentence: We are witnessing not the triumph but the breakdown of democracy. Now, both triumph and breakdown are presented as specific outcomes, and the parallelism is clear. The message becomes more forceful: what we expected (the triumph of democracy) has not happened; instead, we see its breakdown. The original version with not triumph but the breakdown is understandable but slightly less polished in formal writing.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Option A (not the triumph but breakdown) reverses the imbalance: now triumph has an article but breakdown does not, so parallelism is still not achieved. Option C (note triumph but breakdown) contains a spelling error (note instead of not) and is therefore clearly wrong. Option D (No improvement) ignores the chance to make the structure more symmetrical and elegant. Option E (not triumph and not breakdown) changes the meaning, suggesting that neither triumph nor breakdown is being witnessed, which contradicts the intended sense that breakdown, not triumph, is what we see.
Common Pitfalls:
Candidates sometimes focus only on obvious spelling issues like withnessing and overlook subtler stylistic improvements such as parallel article usage. However, sentence improvement questions often assume minor errors like spelling while targeting a deeper grammatical or stylistic point. Another pitfall is to treat not...but... as a fixed pattern that does not allow modifications, but in fact, each side of the contrast must still follow normal grammar, including article use and parallel structure.
Final Answer:
The best improvement is not the triumph but the breakdown, giving: We are witnessing not the triumph but the breakdown of democracy.
Discussion & Comments