Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: had rediscovered
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
Sentence improvement questions test your understanding of tense, aspect, and correct English structure. In this question, the sentence uses the reporting verb thought in the past tense and then refers to an action that was already complete at that time. It is important to recognise when past perfect tense is required in order to show the correct sequence of events, which is a common topic in competitive examinations and formal writing.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
When we narrate two actions in the past and want to show that one happened before the other, we use past perfect for the earlier action and simple past for the later action. Here, the act of rediscovering her real self is earlier, and the act of thinking about it is later. Therefore, the correct structure is She thought she had rediscovered her real self. The phrase have rediscovered is wrong because present perfect does not fit in a clause governed by a past reporting verb in this context.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify the main verb thought, which is in simple past.
Step 2: Recognise that the rediscovery is an action completed before that moment of thought.
Step 3: Apply the rule of sequencing past actions, where the earlier action takes past perfect had plus past participle.
Step 4: Test She thought she had rediscovered and see that it is grammatically correct and meaningful.
Step 5: Reject options that break tense agreement or verb form rules.
Verification / Alternative check:
You can compare with similar correct sentences, such as He realised he had made a mistake or She felt she had achieved her dream. In each case, the realisation or feeling is in simple past, and the completed action before that uses had plus third form of the verb. The pattern matches our sentence exactly. Reading the full corrected sentence She thought she had rediscovered her real self after a long time shows both logical time order and smooth grammar.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Had rediscover uses the auxiliary had but keeps the verb in base form rediscover, which is incorrect because past perfect requires the past participle rediscovered.
Had rediscovering mixes had with an ing form, which does not form any standard tense here and sounds ungrammatical.
No improvement would keep have rediscovered after a past tense reporting verb, which wrongly combines present perfect with past simple in a way that does not fit the meaning of an earlier completed action.
Common Pitfalls:
Learners often confuse have and had in indirect speech and reported thoughts, especially when an action seems emotionally close to the speaker. They may also forget that rediscovered is the third form needed after had. To avoid this, practise identifying which action happened first and always use had plus third form for that action when another past action depends on it.
Final Answer:
The correct improved form is had rediscovered.
Discussion & Comments