Concrete defects — outcomes commonly caused by segregation Segregation of fresh concrete (coarse aggregate separating from mortar) commonly leads to which of the following defects after setting/hardening?
-
AHoneycombed concrete
-
BPorous or weak layers within the concrete section
-
CSurface scaling and poor finish quality
-
DSand streaks and non-uniform texture
-
EAll of the above
Answer
Correct Answer: All of the above
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Segregation occurs when components of fresh concrete separate due to improper proportioning, excessive vibration, high drop heights, or inadequate cohesiveness. The resulting non-uniformity compromises durability, strength, and appearance.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Conventional vibrated concrete.
- Poor handling practices or unstable mixes (e.g., very low fines, high slump without VMA).
- Normal placement conditions with avoidable errors.
Concept / Approach:
When segregation happens, mortar may run off and coarse aggregate clusters, leaving voids and creating honeycombing; stratified layers form, and surface finish suffers, producing scaling and sand streaks. Preventing segregation maintains designed gradation through the section and ensures proper paste coating and cohesion.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recognize mechanism: differential movement of constituents.Map to defects: voids → honeycombing; paste loss → porous layers; non-uniform fines → streaks and poor finishes.Therefore, all listed defects can result from segregation.Verification / Alternative check:
Site QA records link high drop placements and over-vibration with pronounced honeycombing and laitance layers, validating the cause–effect relation.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Each individual defect may occur, but segregation can cause all of them simultaneously; hence the comprehensive choice is correct.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing bleeding (water rising) with segregation; both can co-occur but are distinct.
- Ignoring the role of appropriate grading and admixtures in cohesion.
Final Answer:
All of the above.