Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: SPQR
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This rearrangement question focuses on the theme of science as a boon and the effort behind scientific achievements. The sentences discuss the benefits of science, clarify that these benefits did not arrive effortlessly and explain how they are based on hard work rather than mere observation. To answer correctly, we must identify how an author would typically introduce such an idea, contrast appearance and reality, and conclude with an explanation of the true basis of scientific progress.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
The main approach is to:
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: S is a natural opening sentence because it broadly states that science is the greatest boon to human beings and needs no prior context.
Step 2: P follows S well because it begins with "But", which contrasts the boon of science with the reality that its achievements have not fallen effortlessly into our laps.
Step 3: After clarifying that achievements are not effortless, Q further refines our understanding by saying that science is not just the result of observation and experience.
Step 4: R comes immediately after Q and uses "It is, on the other hand" to provide the real explanation: science results from centuries of hard work, often risky and demanding.
Step 5: Reading S-P-Q-R as a full paragraph gives a smooth argumentative flow from praise, to warning against a simplistic view, to correction and final explanation.
Verification / Alternative check:
Reading SPQR as a continuous paragraph confirms the logic. The first sentence praises science; the second adds that these achievements did not come easily; the third clears misconceptions about the process behind science; the fourth provides the hard work explanation. Any other order disrupts the structure. For example, QPRS begins with a somewhat technical statement about what science is not, which is less natural as an opening. SQRP or QRPS place "But" P or "on the other hand" R in positions where the contrast is unclear or the referent of "It" is not clearly established.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Common Pitfalls:
One common error is ignoring logical connectors like "But" and "on the other hand", which are vital for determining correct order. Another mistake is assuming that any sentence that looks general, such as Q, can start a paragraph even when it actually functions as a correction of a previous misconception. Examine attitude markers like "no doubt", "but", "not just" and "on the other hand" carefully, because they reveal the author's argumentative strategy.
Final Answer:
The correct sequence is SPQR, so the correct option is SPQR.
Discussion & Comments