Frequency dependence of resistance in a metallic wire (skin effect) As operating frequency f increases from low frequency into the radio-frequency range, how does the effective AC resistance of a metallic wire change?
-
AIt increases as f increases (due to skin effect)
-
BIt decreases as f increases
-
CIt remains the same at all frequencies
-
DIt increases with f up to a certain frequency and then decreases at higher f
-
EIt oscillates with frequency due to resonance alone
Answer
Correct Answer: It increases as f increases (due to skin effect)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:In AC conditions, current distribution in conductors becomes non-uniform with frequency. The skin effect forces current toward the surface of the conductor, effectively reducing the cross-sectional area available for conduction and increasing the AC resistance compared with DC resistance. This behavior is fundamental in RF design and power transmission at high frequencies.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Good conductor (e.g., copper) with standard conductivity.
- Frequency f varied from low to high without resonance structures.
- Straight uniform wire to isolate skin effect.
Concept / Approach:
The skin depth δ = √(2 / (ω μ σ)) decreases with increasing angular frequency ω = 2π f. As δ shrinks, current crowds near the surface, reducing effective conducting area and raising AC resistance RAC. Typically, RAC ∝ 1/δ ∝ √f for round wires at sufficiently high frequencies.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Write δ = √(2 / (ω μ σ)) → δ ↓ as f ↑.Effective area Aeff ≈ perimeter × δ for large conductors.RAC ≈ ρ L / Aeff → RAC increases with f (approximately ∝ √f).Verification / Alternative check:
Practical measurements show wire resistance and attenuation per unit length rising with frequency; Litz wire mitigates this by distributing strands to equalize current distribution.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
(b) contradicts skin effect; (c) ignores frequency dependence; (d) suggests a decrease at high f not observed in simple conductors; (e) resonance requires specific reactive networks, not a straight uniform wire.
Common Pitfalls:
Confusing skin effect with proximity effect (current crowding due to nearby conductors); overlooking temperature rise which further increases resistance.
Final Answer:
It increases as f increases (due to skin effect)