Refrigeration fundamentals: The relative coefficient of performance (relative C.O.P.) is defined as the ratio of the actual coefficient of performance to the theoretical (Carnot) coefficient of performance for the same temperature limits.
-
ARelative C.O.P. = Actual C.O.P. / Theoretical (Carnot) C.O.P.
-
BRelative C.O.P. = Theoretical (Carnot) C.O.P. / Actual C.O.P.
-
CActual C.O.P. × Theoretical C.O.P.
-
Dnone of these
-
ERelative C.O.P. = (Actual C.O.P. − Theoretical C.O.P.) / Theoretical C.O.P.
Answer
Correct Answer: Relative C.O.P. = Actual C.O.P. / Theoretical (Carnot) C.O.P.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The “relative coefficient of performance” is a handy performance index in refrigeration that benchmarks a real plant against the best possible ideal cycle working between the same temperature limits. It tells how close the real system comes to the Carnot refrigerator's performance.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Actual C.O.P. refers to Q_L / W for the real system.
- Theoretical (Carnot) C.O.P. is the C.O.P. of an ideal reversible refrigerator operating between the same evaporator and condenser temperatures.
- Temperatures are steady and heat leaks are negligible.
Concept / Approach:Performance comparison must be dimensionless and normalized to the best theoretical limit. Dividing the actual C.O.P. by the Carnot C.O.P. yields a number between 0 and 1 (typically), directly indicating effectiveness relative to the ideal.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Write the definition: Relative C.O.P. = (Actual C.O.P.) / (Carnot C.O.P.).Recall Carnot refrigerator: C.O.P._Carnot = T_L / (T_H − T_L) when temperatures are in kelvin.Compute Actual C.O.P. from test data: C.O.P._actual = Q_L / W_input.Form the ratio to obtain the relative C.O.P.Verification / Alternative check:If a plant operates ideally, Actual C.O.P. equals Carnot C.O.P. and the relative C.O.P. becomes 1. Any irreversibilities will make it less than 1, which matches intuition.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- The reciprocal (Theoretical / Actual) can exceed 1 and does not measure closeness to the ideal correctly.
- The product Actual × Theoretical has incorrect units and no physical meaning.
- “None of these” is wrong because a standard definition exists.
- The difference divided by theoretical gives “percentage shortfall,” not relative C.O.P.
Common Pitfalls:Using Celsius instead of kelvin in Carnot formulas; mixing up ideal heat pump C.O.P. with refrigerator C.O.P.; and comparing to the wrong theoretical temperature limits.
Final Answer:Relative C.O.P. = Actual C.O.P. / Theoretical (Carnot) C.O.P.