A rectangular bar with width b and height h is used as a cantilever. If the loading acts in a plane parallel to the side b (i.e., bending about the weak axis), what is the section modulus?
-
AZ = b * h^2 / 6
-
BZ = h * b^2 / 6
-
CZ = b^2 * h / 12
-
DZ = h^2 * b / 12
Answer
Correct Answer: Z = h * b^2 / 6
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The section modulus Z determines the bending stress for a given bending moment via σ = M / Z. For rectangles, Z depends on which axis the section bends about (strong vs weak axis). Correctly identifying the bending axis is crucial for safe design.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Rectangle: width b, height h.
- Loading plane is parallel to side b → bending about the weak axis (through the centroid, parallel to side b), hence the moment of inertia uses b^2.
- Linear elastic bending.
Concept / Approach:Section modulus Z = I / c, where I is the second moment of area about the bending axis and c is the distance from centroid to the extreme fiber along the bending direction.
Step-by-Step Solution:For bending about the weak axis: I_weak = h * b^3 / 12.Extreme fiber distance c = b/2.Z = I / c = (h * b^3 / 12) / (b/2) = h * b^2 / 6.
Verification / Alternative check:Compare with strong-axis bending where I_strong = b * h^3 / 12 and Z_strong = b * h^2 / 6; the provided loading plane distinguishes the weak-axis case.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Z = b * h^2 / 6: strong-axis result, not applicable here.
- Z = b^2 * h / 12 and Z = h^2 * b / 12: these are moments of inertia divided by incorrect c or simply incorrect expressions.
Common Pitfalls:
- Confusing which side corresponds to c and which formula for I to use.
Final Answer:Z = h * b^2 / 6