Peaking for large trunk mains: For trunk sewers with diameters greater than 1.25 m, the ratio of maximum sewage flow to average sewage flow is typically:
-
A1.5
-
B2.0
-
C3.0
-
D4.0
-
E1.2
Answer
Correct Answer: 1.5
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Large trunk mains experience flow attenuation due to substantial storage and long travel times. Consequently, the peaking factor (max/average) is lower than for small laterals or branch sewers.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Diameter > 1.25 m implies significant hydraulic storage and wave smoothing.
- Diurnal peaks are damped by upstream networks and in-sewer storage.
- Standard peaking factors are used for preliminary design.
Concept / Approach:Empirical peaking factors reduce with increasing contributing area and pipe size. For large trunks, a value near 1.5 is commonly adopted to reflect reduced peak-to-average variation.
Step-by-Step Solution:Recognize that larger systems peak less sharply.Choose a conservative yet typical factor.Select 1.5 as a representative ratio for large trunks.
Verification / Alternative check:Several design guides present peaking factors decreasing toward ~1.3–1.7 for major interceptors, depending on catchment size and infiltration/inflow characteristics.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:2.0–4.0: represent small sewers or localized peaks; high for large trunks.1.2: optimistic and may under-design capacity.
Common Pitfalls:
- Applying small-system peaking factors to city-scale interceptors.
- Ignoring wet-weather inflow that can modify effective peaks.
Final Answer:1.5