What was the rate of interest on a sum of money? I. The sum fetched a total of ₹ 2522 as compound interest at the end of 3 years. II. The difference between the simple interest and the compound interest at the end of 2 years at the same rate was ₹ 40.
Aptitude
Compound Interest
Difficulty: Hard
Choose an option
-
AI alone is sufficient
-
BII alone is sufficient
-
CBoth I and II are necessary to answer
-
DNeither I nor II is sufficient to answer
Answer
Correct Answer: Both I and II are necessary to answer
Explanation
### Concept & Compound Interest Data Sufficiency
To find the rate of interest ($R$), we need enough information to form a solvable equation. The key formulas are Compound Interest $CI = P((1 + \frac{R}{100})^n - 1)$ and the difference for 2 years $CI - SI = P(\frac{R}{100})^2$.
### Step-by-Step Solution
1. **Statement I alone:** Gives $CI$ for 3 years = ₹ 2522. We have $P((1 + \frac{R}{100})^3 - 1) = 2522$. Two variables ($P$ and $R$), one equation. Not sufficient.
2. **Statement II alone:** Gives $CI - SI$ for 2 years = ₹ 40. We have $P(\frac{R}{100})^2 = 40$. Two variables, one equation. Not sufficient.
3. **Combining I and II:** We have two distinct equations with two variables.
Substitute $P = \frac{40}{(\frac{R}{100})^2}$ into the first equation to solve for $R$.
Since this yields a unique positive root for practical interest rates ($R = 5\%$), both statements together are sufficient.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
In data sufficiency, you do not need to calculate the exact final value. Once you establish that you have $n$ independent equations for $n$ variables (and confirm they are not degenerate or multi-root in the practical domain), you can confidently deduce sufficiency.
### Common Pitfall
Assuming two equations are always sufficient without checking for independence or multiple roots. Always mentally verify that a unique solution exists.
### Final Answer
Therefore, the correct answer is **Both I and II are necessary to answer**.