Purely cohesive (φ = 0) slope — critical circle: In a purely cohesive soil (φ = 0) slope, the critical center of the circular slip surface lies at the intersection of:
-
AThe perpendicular bisector of the slope face and the locus of centers
-
BA perpendicular drawn at one-third of the slope length from the toe and the locus of centers
-
CA perpendicular drawn at two-thirds of the slope from the toe and the locus of centers
-
DThe line of directional angles with the slope normal
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: A perpendicular drawn at one-third of the slope length from the toe and the locus of centers
Explanation
Introduction / Context:For homogeneous slopes, Swedish circle (method of slices) and stability charts provide critical slip surfaces. In the special case of purely cohesive soil (φ = 0), classical results locate the critical circle center using simple geometrical rules that aid preliminary design checks.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Homogeneous soil with φ = 0 (purely cohesive).
- Planar ground surface forming a slope with a defined toe and crest.
- Classical circular slip surface assumption.
Concept / Approach:For φ = 0 slopes, the most critical (minimum factor of safety) circle is found at the intersection of the locus of potential centers and a perpendicular erected at one-third of the slope length measured from the toe. This geometric rule stems from analyses that balance driving and resisting moments for fully cohesive materials.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Mark the slope toe and measure the slope length along the face.At a point one-third of this length from the toe, draw a perpendicular to the slope face.Determine the locus of possible circle centers (standard construction line).Their intersection gives the center of the critical slip circle for φ = 0.Verification / Alternative check:Stability charts (Taylor’s stability numbers for φ = 0) and trial slip-circle analyses confirm this location for the critical circle in cohesive slopes.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Perpendicular bisector or two-thirds position: do not match the established φ = 0 rule.
- Directional angles with slope normal: not the classical geometric construction for cohesive slopes.
Common Pitfalls:Applying this geometric rule to c–φ soils with φ > 0 where the critical center location differs; ignoring groundwater effects that alter stability.
Final Answer:A perpendicular drawn at one-third of the slope length from the toe and the locus of centers