Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: Wife of Chotu's father
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This question is very similar to a classic family relation puzzle. Kiran is looking at a photograph of a lady and describes herself as the only daughter of that lady. She then adds that the lady's son is the maternal uncle of Chotu. We need to determine how Kiran is related to Chotu's father. The problem tests understanding of maternal uncle and the roles of mothers and fathers in a simple family tree.
Given Data / Assumptions:
• Kiran is the only daughter of the lady in the photograph.• The lady also has a son who is the maternal uncle of Chotu.• A maternal uncle is the brother of one's mother.• Kiran and the son in question are both children of the same lady.• Standard family structure is assumed.
Concept / Approach:
If the son of the lady in the photograph is Chotu's maternal uncle, then he is the brother of Chotu's mother. That makes the lady in the photograph Chotu's maternal grandmother. Kiran is the only daughter of this grandmother, so she is also a child of the same grandmother and therefore a sister of Chotu's maternal uncle. As a sister of Chotu's maternal uncle and a daughter of the maternal grandmother, Kiran is very naturally Chotu's mother. If she is Chotu's mother, then with respect to Chotu's father she must be his wife.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Let the lady in the photograph be G. Kiran is the only daughter of G.Step 2: G has a son who is the maternal uncle of Chotu.Step 3: If that son is maternal uncle of Chotu, he is brother of Chotu's mother.Step 4: Therefore, the mother of Chotu, call her M, is also a child of G, making G the maternal grandmother of Chotu.Step 5: G has exactly one daughter, Kiran. Thus, Kiran must be the same person as M, the mother of Chotu.Step 6: Hence, Kiran is Chotu's mother.Step 7: From the point of view of Chotu's father, the mother of Chotu is his wife.
Verification / Alternative check:
Draw a small family tree where G is the grandmother. She has two children, a son U and a daughter Kiran. U is the maternal uncle of Chotu, and Kiran is the only daughter of G. For U to be the maternal uncle, Kiran has to be Chotu's mother. No other arrangement satisfies both the only daughter condition and the maternal uncle condition at the same time. Thus the conclusion that Kiran is the mother of Chotu is forced, and she must therefore be the wife of Chotu's father.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Cousin of Chotu's father: This would place Kiran in a different branch of the family, which does not fit the grandmother and maternal uncle description.Daughter of Chotu's father: This would make Kiran a child of Chotu's father and of the grandmother in the photograph, which is impossible.Sister of Chotu's father: That would make the uncle paternal, not maternal.Mother of Chotu's father: This role is already played by G, the grandmother in the photograph.
Common Pitfalls:
Some candidates confuse whether the woman in the photograph is the mother or the grandmother of Chotu. Remember, if her son is Chotu's maternal uncle, she must be the maternal grandmother. Then, because Kiran is the only daughter of this grandmother, Kiran has to be Chotu's mother. Recognising these steps avoids misclassification of the relationship.
Final Answer:
Kiran is the wife of Chotu's father.
Discussion & Comments