In plastic analysis, what is the shape factor (M_p / M_y) for a triangular cross-section (about its centroidal axis in bending)?
-
A1.5
-
B1.34
-
C2.34
-
D2.5
Answer
Correct Answer: 2.34
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The shape factor indicates how much plastic moment capacity exceeds the elastic yield moment for a given section shape. Triangular sections have a larger shape factor than rectangles and circles because a greater proportion of the area lies away from the neutral axis, enabling more plastic redistribution after first yield.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Elastic–perfectly plastic material in bending.
- Triangular cross-section, bending about a centroidal axis parallel to the base.
- Plane sections remain plane; full plasticity possible.
Concept / Approach:M_y depends on elastic section modulus, while M_p is obtained by balancing equal tension and compression areas at yield stress. For a triangular section, the standard result is f = M_p / M_y ≈ 2.34, significantly higher than rectangular (1.5) or circular (≈1.7) sections.
Step-by-Step Solution:Step 1: Recall definition of shape factor f = M_p / M_y.Step 2: Use known tabulated values for common shapes.Step 3: For triangle, f ≈ 2.34; select 2.34.
Verification / Alternative check:Plastic design references consistently list triangular section shape factor close to 2.34, validating the choice.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 1.5: Rectangular section value.
- 1.34: Not a standard shape factor for a triangle.
- 2.5: Higher than accepted value for a triangle.
Common Pitfalls:Misremembering the ordering (triangle > circle > rectangle); using material-dependent values rather than geometric constants.
Final Answer:2.34