Difficulty: Medium
Correct Answer: They are relatively near and appear as small discs rather than point sources.
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This question belongs to general astronomy and observational science. In the night sky, stars appear to twinkle, whereas planets generally shine with a steadier light. Understanding the optical reason behind this difference helps clarify how distance and apparent size influence what we see from Earth.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Stars twinkle, planets usually do not.
- The observer is on Earth, looking through the atmosphere.
- The options suggest different physical reasons, including distance and optical effects.
Concept / Approach:
Twinkling, or stellar scintillation, occurs because starlight passes through layers of air with varying density and temperature. A star is so distant that it appears as a point source, so these variations cause its light intensity and position to change rapidly, producing twinkling. Planets are much closer to Earth than stars and appear as tiny discs. The effects of atmospheric turbulence average out across the disc, so the overall light remains steadier and planets do not twinkle noticeably.
Step-by-Step Solution:
1. Recognize that stars are extremely distant and appear as point sources.
2. Planets, although far away, are still much closer than stars and appear as small discs in telescopes.
3. Atmospheric refraction varies rapidly, causing intensity fluctuations for point sources.
4. For extended sources like planetary discs, the fluctuations average out.
5. Therefore, planets do not twinkle like stars mainly because they are nearer and have larger apparent size.
Verification / Alternative check:
Observational astronomy guides and textbooks explain that stars twinkle due to atmospheric turbulence acting on point sources, while planets typically show a steady light. This explanation matches the reasoning above.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
Very far distance: Stars are much farther than planets, so distance alone does not explain the difference.
Total internal reflection: The main effect is atmospheric refraction and turbulence, not total internal reflection.
Refraction does not affect planets: Refraction affects all incoming light, but its effect is averaged out for extended sources like planets.
Common Pitfalls:
A common misconception is that planets and stars behave differently because of their physical nature alone. While physical nature matters, the key observational reason for twinkling is the combination of atmospheric conditions and apparent size as seen from Earth.
Final Answer:
Planets do not twinkle like stars mainly because they are relatively near and appear as small discs rather than point sources.
Discussion & Comments