Vertical loop dynamics (aviation mechanics): A pilot flies a small aircraft in a vertical loop of radius r. If he experiences weightlessness at the top of the loop, what speed v must the plane have at that top position (take gravitational acceleration = g)?
-
Av = 0
-
Bv = √(g r)
-
Cv = g r
-
Dv = √(2 g r)
-
Ev → ∞
Answer
Correct Answer: v = √(g r)
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Looping maneuvers are analyzed with circular motion dynamics. At the top of a vertical loop, a pilot feels weightless when the normal reaction from the seat becomes zero. That condition sets a critical relationship between speed, loop radius, and gravitational acceleration.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Radius of loop = r.
- Acceleration due to gravity = g.
- Point-mass aircraft model at the loop apex; no lift contribution at the instant (worst case for weightlessness criterion).
Concept / Approach:At the top, centripetal acceleration a_c must be provided entirely by gravity when apparent weight (normal reaction N) is zero. Using the circular motion condition a_c = v^2 / r and setting N = 0 leads directly to the required speed for weightlessness.
Step-by-Step Solution:
At top: sum of forces toward center = m * v^2 / r.Toward center is downward; gravity contributes m * g; normal reaction N = 0 for weightlessness.Therefore m * g = m * v^2 / r → v^2 = g * r.Hence v = √(g r).Verification / Alternative check:Any speed less than √(g r) makes v^2 / r < g, so N must act downward (cannot), meaning the pilot would not stay in contact without restraints. Speeds greater than √(g r) create positive normal forces (apparent weight).
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- A: Zero speed cannot maintain the loop and ignores centripetal requirements.
- C: g r is acceleration units times length; missing the square root makes dimensions incorrect.
- D: √(2 g r) corresponds to a larger speed than necessary for N = 0.
- E: Infinite speed is physically unnecessary and impossible.
Common Pitfalls:Forgetting to set N = 0 for weightlessness; neglecting direction of centripetal acceleration at the apex; dimensional mistakes such as choosing g r instead of √(g r).
Final Answer:v = √(g r)