Ignition Timing and Knock – Effect of Advancing Spark in Petrol Engines In a spark-ignition petrol engine, what is the effect on knocking tendency if the spark timing is advanced (spark occurs earlier before top dead centre)?

Mechanical Engineering IC Engines and Nuclear Power Plants Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    not affect the knocking tendency
  • B
    decrease
  • C
    increase
  • D
    first decrease then increase
  • E
    eliminate knock entirely

Answer

Correct Answer: increase

Explanation

Introduction / Context:Ignition timing is a powerful lever in spark-ignition engines. Advancing or retarding the spark changes the pressure–temperature history of the unburned end-gas and therefore the likelihood of knock. Understanding this relationship is vital for engine calibration, particularly under high load where knock limits torque and compression ratio.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Constant compression ratio and fuel octane rating.
  • Load high enough that knock is a limiting factor.
  • No active knock-control interventions assumed.

Concept / Approach:

Advancing the spark starts combustion earlier in the compression stroke. This increases the time the end-gas spends at elevated pressure and temperature before the flame front arrives. The longer residence at high temperature raises the chance of auto-ignition, thereby increasing knock tendency. Retarding the spark reduces the end-gas exposure and typically suppresses knock but may reduce efficiency and torque if excessive.

Step-by-Step Solution:

Advance spark → earlier heat release → higher pressure and temperature sooner.End-gas is subjected to severe conditions for longer.Probability of auto-ignition rises.Therefore, advancing spark increases knocking tendency.

Verification / Alternative check:

Knock sensors in modern engines detect onset of knock and automatically retard timing to eliminate it, reflecting the strong positive relation between spark advance and knock intensity at a given fuel octane.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:

“Not affect” is incorrect because timing strongly affects knock. “Decrease” reverses the known trend. “First decrease then increase” lacks basis under fixed conditions. “Eliminate entirely” is unrealistic; spark advance cannot remove knock by itself.

Common Pitfalls:

Confusing MBT (minimum advance for best torque) timing with knock-limited timing; at high load, MBT may be beyond the knock limit, requiring retard to avoid knock even if torque drops slightly.

Final Answer:

increase

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion