Classification – Odd one out (tool → object of action) Three pairs name a tool and the typical object it acts upon. One pair names two similar stationary items rather than a tool–target relation. Identify the odd pair.
-
AShovel : Mud
-
BScrewdriver : Screw
-
CHammer : Nail
-
DPen : Pencil
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: Pen : Pencil
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Tool–target relations are common: the first item is used to act on/with the second (shovel→mud, screwdriver→screw, hammer→nail). A distractor may pair two peer items without an action relation. Spotting the presence or absence of directed action is decisive.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Shovel : Mud
- Screwdriver : Screw
- Hammer : Nail
- Pen : Pencil
Concept / Approach:Ask: “Is the second noun the usual object the first acts on?” Three are yes. One is simply two writing instruments, not instrument→target.
Step-by-Step Solution:Shovel moves/handles mud → tool→material.Screwdriver drives/removes a screw → tool→object.Hammer drives a nail → tool→object.Pen and pencil are co-category writing tools → not tool→target → odd one out.
Verification / Alternative check:Swap order: “nail : hammer,” “screw : screwdriver,” “mud : shovel” remain meaningful as target→tool. “pencil : pen” gives peer→peer, not actional symmetry, confirming the mismatch.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Shovel : Mud → action relation present.
- Screwdriver : Screw → action relation present.
- Hammer : Nail → action relation present.
- None of these → only one lacks the relation (Pen : Pencil).
Common Pitfalls:Accepting “pen : pencil” due to domain similarity. Classification demands relation uniformity, not mere topical similarity.
Final Answer:Pen : Pencil