Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: C
Explanation:
Introduction / Context:
This is a classification question involving musical instruments. We are asked to identify which instrument differs in type from the others. Understanding basic categories of instruments, such as string, keyboard, and wind, helps in selecting the odd one out. The letters A, B, C, and D refer to Violin, Piano, Flute, and Harmonium respectively.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach:
Violin is primarily a string instrument, where sound is produced by vibrating strings using a bow. Piano and harmonium are broadly keyboard instruments, where sound is produced either by strings struck by hammers in the case of the piano or by air passing through reeds controlled by keys in the case of the harmonium. Flute, however, is a wind instrument, where sound is produced by air flow through a tube. Therefore, Flute is of a different instrument family compared to the others.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: Identify Violin as a string instrument played with a bow on strings.
Step 2: Identify Piano as a keyboard instrument in which pressing keys causes hammers to strike strings.
Step 3: Identify Harmonium as a keyboard based reed instrument in which pressing keys allows air to flow through reeds to produce sound.
Step 4: Identify Flute as a wind instrument where sound is produced by blowing air across holes in a hollow tube.
Step 5: Observe that Violin, Piano, and Harmonium can be grouped by string or keyboard categories, whereas Flute stands alone as a pure wind instrument.
Verification / Alternative check:
We can also group the instruments based on how the player interacts with them. Violin, Piano, and Harmonium all involve pressing or drawing across a physical component such as strings or keys, with air flow being secondary in the harmonium. Flute, on the other hand, demands direct blowing of air and finger placement on holes, and does not use keys in the way keyboard instruments do. This reinforces the idea that C, representing Flute, is structurally and functionally distinct from the others.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
A (Violin): A string instrument but shares general musical context with Piano and Harmonium and does not uniquely stand out by category here.
B (Piano): A keyboard string instrument, but still not as fundamentally different as the wind based Flute.
D (Harmonium): A keyboard reed instrument, which is closer to Piano in playing style than to Flute.
None of the above: This would be true only if all four instruments belonged to the same major category, which is not the case.
Common Pitfalls:
A common mistake is to think that Violin is the odd one because it is not a keyboard instrument, while Piano and Harmonium clearly are. However, the more prominent classification used in many reasoning questions separates wind instruments from string and keyboard instruments, and only Flute belongs to the wind family among the given options.
Final Answer:
The instrument that is of a different type compared to the others is represented by option C, that is, the Flute.
Discussion & Comments