Constitutive Behavior — In which class of fluids is the shear stress–shear rate relation non-linear over practical ranges?
-
ANewtonian fluids only
-
BNon-Newtonian fluids
-
CBoth Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids equally
-
DNone of these
-
EIdeal gases under all conditions
Answer
Correct Answer: Non-Newtonian fluids
Explanation
Introduction:Designing mixers, pumps, and pipelines requires knowing how shear stress tau depends on shear rate gamma_dot. Newtonian fluids have tau = mu * gamma_dot (a straight line through the origin), whereas non-Newtonian fluids deviate from linearity, often dramatically, affecting power draw and pressure drop.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Continuum regime with isothermal conditions.
- Definition: Newtonian if viscosity is constant and tau proportional to gamma_dot.
- Non-Newtonian if viscosity depends on rate and/or time.
Concept / Approach:
Non-Newtonian classes include shear-thinning, shear-thickening, Bingham plastic, Herschel–Bulkley, thixotropic, and rheopectic behaviors. Each yields a non-linear tau–gamma_dot curve or incorporates a yield stress, invalidating a single constant viscosity description across operating ranges.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recognize that Newtonian relationship is linear by definition.Identify non-Newtonian models where tau depends on gamma_dot non-linearly.Conclude non-Newtonian fluids exhibit the non-linear relation of interest.Select the option explicitly naming non-Newtonian fluids.Verification / Alternative check:
Rheometer measurements for paints, ketchup, polymer melts, and cell broths show curved tau–gamma_dot plots, unlike water or mineral oils at moderate rates.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
A: Newtonian is linear by definition. C and D: Incorrect generalizations. E: Gas behavior is not directly a constitutive fluid class and under most laminar conditions ideal gases behave Newtonian.
Common Pitfalls:
Using a single viscosity number for complex fluids; always report the shear rate (and time history if relevant).
Final Answer:
Non-Newtonian fluids