Statement–Assumption (Institutions as Engines of Development): Statement: “If a region is crying for development, establish a new university, an advanced medical institute, and a centre for agricultural research there—and wait for the results.” Assumptions: I) Creating new states alone would not speed up development. II) Development can be accelerated by spreading education and research capacity through such institutions.
-
Aif only assumption I is implicit.
-
Bif only assumption II is implicit.
-
Cif either I or II is implicit.
-
Dif neither I nor II is implicit.
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: if only assumption II is implicit.
Explanation
Introduction / Context:The statement proposes a concrete remedy for underdevelopment: build higher-education, medical, and agricultural research institutions and allow time for impact. The core question is: what belief must be true for this prescription to be sensible?
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Policy lever: establish knowledge/health/research institutions.
- Goal: regional development.
Concept / Approach:For the recommendation to be meaningful, one must accept that such institutions catalyse development (human capital, health outcomes, innovation, productivity spillovers). Discussion about “new states” is a separate political remedy not referenced in the statement and hence not required as an assumption.
Step-by-Step Solution:Assumption II: Necessary. Without believing that universities, medical institutes, and research centres drive development, the advice lacks rationale.Assumption I: Not necessary. The statement does not contrast its remedy against statehood/federal restructuring; it simply prescribes an institutional pathway.
Verification / Alternative check:Negate II (institutions do not aid development) and the recommendation collapses. Negate I (state creation could help) yet the institutional remedy could still be valid—thus I is not required.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:“Only I” and “Either/Neither” overlook the indispensable causal link between institutions and development.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming the statement is about political federalism; it is about knowledge/health infrastructure as development engines.
Final Answer:Only assumption II is implicit.