Two-stage compression with perfect intercooling: If n1 and n2 are the polytropic indices in stage-1 and stage-2, then the work ratio with equal pressure ratios is W1/W2 = [n1/(n1 − 1)] / [n2/(n2 − 1)].

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: W1/W2 = [n1/(n1 − 1)] / [n2/(n2 − 1)]

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
In multi-stage air compression with perfect intercooling and equal pressure ratios per stage, each stage can follow a different polytropic index n. Comparing stage works helps in assessing valve timing, cooling, and stage matching.



Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Two stages with polytropic indices n1 (stage-1) and n2 (stage-2).
  • Perfect intercooling restores the interstage temperature to the initial suction temperature.
  • Equal pressure ratios per stage.
  • Ideal gas behavior with constant specific heats.


Concept / Approach:
For polytropic compression p * v^n = constant, the specific work (per unit mass) is proportional to n/(n − 1) times a function of the pressure ratio raised to (n − 1)/n. With equal pressure ratios and identical inlet temperature to each stage (due to perfect intercooling), the ratio of works reduces to the ratio of n/(n − 1) factors.



Step-by-Step Solution:

For a stage: w = [n/(n − 1)] * R * T_in * [(r)^((n − 1)/n) − 1].With equal r and same T_in for both stages, the bracketed term is equal for each.Therefore, W1/W2 = [n1/(n1 − 1)] / [n2/(n2 − 1)].This compares only the polytropic factors, since other terms cancel.


Verification / Alternative check:
If n1 = n2, the ratio becomes 1, matching the expectation that both stages do equal work under perfect intercooling with equal pressure ratios.



Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Inverse ratio: Swaps the stage roles incorrectly.
  • (n1 − 1)/(n2 − 1): Omits the n terms; not dimensionally consistent with polytropic work dependence.
  • n2/n1: Also incorrect; polytropic work does not scale simply as n.


Common Pitfalls:
Assuming stage work equality without checking n values; perfect intercooling equalizes temperatures, but differing n values still change the polytropic factor.



Final Answer:
W1/W2 = [n1/(n1 − 1)] / [n2/(n2 − 1)]

More Questions from Compressors, Gas Dynamics and Gas Turbines

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion