Difficulty: Easy
Correct Answer: Two times
Explanation:
Introduction / Context: For axisymmetric circular sections (solid or hollow), in-plane centroidal moments about X–X and Y–Y are equal. The polar moment about the perpendicular centroidal axis equals the sum of these two equal in-plane moments.
Given Data / Assumptions:
Concept / Approach: By definition, J_z (polar) = I_x + I_y. For any circular (axisymmetric) section, I_x = I_y. Hence J_z = 2 I_x. Therefore, the polar moment is two times either in-plane centroidal moment.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Symmetry: I_x = I_y for a circular annulus. Polar relation: J_z = I_x + I_y. Thus J_z = 2 I_x ⇒ “Two times”.Verification / Alternative check: For a thin ring of radius R and area A, I_x = I_y = (A R^2)/2 and J_z = A R^2. Indeed, J_z = 2 * I_x holds exactly.
Why Other Options Are Wrong: “Same” ignores J_z = I_x + I_y; “Half” and “Four times” contradict the exact identity for axisymmetric sections.
Common Pitfalls: Confusing mass polar moment with area polar moment; misapplying the relation J = I_x + I_y to non-centroidal axes.
Final Answer: Two times.
Discussion & Comments