Path-independence of state properties: A system goes from state 1 to state 3 via path 1–2–3 with Q = +100 kJ and W = +60 kJ. Along an alternative path 1–4–3, the work is W = +20 kJ. What heat Q is absorbed along 1–4–3 (kJ)?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: +60 kJ

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This problem tests recognition that internal energy is a state property and therefore path independent. While heat and work depend on the path, their difference (for a closed system neglecting KE/PE changes) equals the change in internal energy between the same end states.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Closed system; sign convention: heat to system positive, work by system positive.
  • Path 1–2–3: Q_123 = +100 kJ, W_123 = +60 kJ.
  • Path 1–4–3: W_143 = +20 kJ; Q_143 = ?


Concept / Approach:
First law for a closed system: ΔU = Q − W. Since states 1 and 3 are the same regardless of path, ΔU_123 = ΔU_143. Compute ΔU from the known path, then solve for the unknown heat on the alternative path using the same ΔU value.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Compute ΔU from 1–2–3: ΔU = Q − W = 100 − 60 = +40 kJ.Apply first law to 1–4–3: ΔU = Q − W.Substitute ΔU = +40 kJ and W = +20 kJ: 40 = Q − 20.Solve for Q: Q = 40 + 20 = +60 kJ.


Verification / Alternative check:
Check consistency: Larger work on the first path (60 kJ) required larger heat input (100 kJ) to reach the same ΔU; with smaller work (20 kJ) on the second path, proportionally smaller heat (60 kJ) is needed to maintain ΔU = +40 kJ.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • −140, −80, −40 kJ: Incorrect sign/magnitude; they would imply a different ΔU, violating state-function path independence.


Common Pitfalls:
Using Q + W instead of Q − W; forgetting the sign convention (work by system positive).


Final Answer:
+60 kJ

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion