More Questions from Hydraulic Machines

Identify the turbine type that is not an impulse turbine from the list below (consider the primary energy conversion principle at the runner).

Mechanical Engineering Hydraulic Machines Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
  • A
    Girad turbine
  • B
    Turgo turbine
  • C
    Pelton wheel
  • D
    Kaplan turbine
  • E
    Banki (cross-flow) turbine

Answer

Correct Answer: Kaplan turbine

Explanation

Introduction:Hydraulic turbines are broadly classified as impulse or reaction types. Impulse turbines extract energy solely through jet momentum at essentially atmospheric pressure in the runner, whereas reaction turbines experience a pressure drop across the runner passages.

Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Compare by operating principle, not geometry alone.
  • Impulse examples: Pelton, Turgo, cross-flow (Banki, as commonly categorized in practice).
  • Reaction examples: Kaplan (axial), Francis (mixed).

Concept / Approach:Kaplan turbines are axial-flow reaction machines with adjustable runner blades and a draft tube, operating with substantial pressure change across the runner. In contrast, Pelton, Turgo, and Girard are classical impulse designs using free jets. Cross-flow turbines are generally treated as impulse machines because the runner operates with jets at near-atmospheric pressure, even though the flow path is through the runner interior.

Step-by-Step Solution:1) Classify each listed turbine by principle.2) Identify which experiences pressure drop in the runner (reaction).3) Kaplan is reaction; others listed are impulse.

Verification / Alternative check:Presence of draft tube and submerged outlet is a hallmark of reaction turbines like Kaplan.

Why Other Options Are Wrong:Girad/Turgo/Pelton: classic impulse types.

Banki (cross-flow): commonly treated as impulse; runner sees atmospheric pressure jets.

Common Pitfalls:Confusing flow direction (axial vs radial) with impulse/reaction classification; they are related but not the same criterion.

Final Answer:Kaplan turbine

Discussion & Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion