Serviceability limit state: the maximum vertical deflection of a structural member should not normally exceed the lesser of span/350 or which fixed limit (in millimetres)?
-
A10 mm
-
B15 mm
-
C20 mm
-
D25 mm
-
E30 mm
Answer
Correct Answer: 20 mm
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Deflection limits protect finishes, partitions, and user comfort. Many specifications cap deflection by a span ratio and also impose an absolute millimetre limit to prevent noticeable sag in shorter spans. The governing requirement is the lesser (more restrictive) of the two criteria.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Deflection criterion includes a span-based term: span/350.
- An absolute millimetre cap also applies.
- We must identify the fixed limit commonly paired with span/350.
Concept / Approach:
Typical serviceability provisions for finished members (ceilings, claddings) set the absolute deflection cap at 20 mm. Hence, the allowable deflection is min(span/350, 20 mm), ensuring both proportional control for long spans and absolute control for short spans.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Write combined limit: δ_allow = min(span/350, 20 mm).Interpretation: choose whichever is smaller to be more conservative.Select 20 mm as the fixed limit value.Verification / Alternative check:
Project specifications often refine limits (e.g., span/250 for total long-term). The 20 mm cap is a common baseline for members supporting brittle finishes.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- 10 or 15 mm: More restrictive than typical baseline; used only in special cases.
- 25 or 30 mm: Too permissive; could lead to visible sag or cracking in finishes.
Common Pitfalls:
- Applying only the span ratio and ignoring the absolute limit, which can be critical for short spans.
- Failing to account for long-term effects (creep) when checking final deflection.
Final Answer:
20 mm