Azeotropes and Raoult’s law: a binary azeotrope that boils at a temperature higher than either pure component shows which kind of deviation from Raoult’s law?
-
APositive deviation
-
BNegative deviation
-
CNo deviation (ideal)
-
DNone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: Negative deviation
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Understanding deviations from Raoult’s law is essential to predict vapor–liquid equilibria, design distillation columns, and anticipate azeotrope formation. Maximum-boiling and minimum-boiling azeotropes exhibit characteristic deviations that influence separation feasibility.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Binary liquid mixture at atmospheric pressure.
- Azeotrope has a boiling point higher than that of both pure components (maximum-boiling azeotrope).
Concept / Approach:Raoult’s law assumes ideal solutions where each component’s partial pressure equals its mole fraction times its pure-component vapor pressure. Real mixtures may deviate because of intermolecular interactions. Stronger unlike-molecule attractions reduce escaping tendency, lowering total vapor pressure at a given temperature. This produces a higher boiling point than either component and constitutes negative deviation from Raoult’s law.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Identify azeotrope type: “higher boiling than either component” → maximum-boiling.Relate to total pressure: stronger attractions → lower total vapor pressure at composition → higher boiling temperature.Conclude deviation sign: interactions stronger than ideal → negative deviation.Verification / Alternative check:Systems like hydrochloric acid–water at certain compositions display maximum-boiling behavior consistent with negative deviations (enhanced attractions).
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Positive deviation: corresponds to weaker unlike interactions, lower boiling, and minimum-boiling azeotropes.
- No deviation: would be ideal behavior, no azeotrope.
- None of these: not applicable because negative deviation is correct.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing sign of deviation with direction of boiling point; assuming all azeotropes are minimum-boiling; ignoring pressure dependence of azeotrope behavior.
Final Answer:Negative deviation