In thin-walled pressure vessels (mechanical design), the “hoop stress” refers specifically to which type of stress acting around the shell of a cylindrical tank?
-
Aradial
-
Bcircumferential tensile
-
Ccompressive
-
Dlongitudinal
-
Enone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: circumferential tensile
Explanation
Introduction / Context:In mechanical and process equipment design, thin cylindrical shells (such as storage tanks, boilers, and heat-exchanger shells) develop distinct stress components when subjected to internal pressure. Two principal membrane stresses are important for safe design: the hoop (circumferential) stress and the longitudinal (axial) stress. Correctly identifying the hoop stress helps engineers size the wall thickness and select materials to prevent failure.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Thin-walled cylinder assumption (wall thickness much smaller than diameter).
- Uniform internal pressure acting on the inner surface.
- Elastic behavior; neglecting local discontinuities and nozzle effects for the concept.
Concept / Approach:Hoop stress acts tangentially around the circumference of the cylinder as the shell “tries to split open” along a longitudinal line. Under thin-wall theory, hoop stress is larger than longitudinal stress by a factor of two for a closed-end cylinder at the same pressure and radius, hence it is often the governing stress state for thickness calculation.
Step-by-Step Solution:
Recognize that internal pressure creates tensile stresses within the shell.Hoop (circumferential) stress acts around the cylinder’s circumference; longitudinal stress acts along its length.Radial stress through the wall is small compared with membrane stresses under thin-wall assumptions.Therefore, “hoop stress” specifically means circumferential tensile stress.Verification / Alternative check:From thin-wall formulas: hoop stress σ_h = p * r / t; longitudinal stress σ_l = p * r / (2 * t). The larger value and direction confirm its circumferential tensile nature.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:
- Radial: small through-thickness stress; not the hoop stress.
- Compressive: internal pressure creates tension in the wall, not compression.
- Longitudinal: a real component, but different from hoop stress.
Common Pitfalls:Confusing hoop with longitudinal stress; applying thick-wall formulas when the thin-wall criterion is not satisfied; ignoring joint efficiency and corrosion allowance in real designs.
Final Answer:circumferential tensile