In electrical insulation and materials engineering, the term for the maximum electric stress a material can withstand without dielectric rupture or flashover is often confused. State whether the following statement is accurate: “The maximum potential a material can withstand without rupture is called breakdown voltage.”

Difficulty: Easy

Correct Answer: Incorrect

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Engineers frequently encounter two closely related terms when discussing insulation limits: breakdown voltage and dielectric strength. Although they are connected, they are not identical. Confusing these terms can lead to poor component selection, over-stressed designs, and avoidable failures in high-voltage power supplies, cables, and capacitors.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • The statement claims a definition for the “maximum potential a material can withstand without rupture.”
  • We are discussing intrinsic properties of insulating media (solid, liquid, gas) versus device- or geometry-specific ratings.
  • No particular thickness or geometry is specified in the statement.


Concept / Approach:
Dielectric strength is a material property expressed as an electric field value (for example, kV/mm). It indicates the maximum field the material can withstand without breakdown. Breakdown voltage is a system or specimen value that depends on geometry, thickness, surface condition, and environment. For a given sample of thickness t, the breakdown voltage V_bd ≈ (dielectric strength) * t, assuming uniform fields and ideal conditions. Thus, calling the general “maximum potential a material can withstand” a breakdown voltage ignores the crucial dependence on thickness and geometry and is not strictly correct as a general materials definition.


Step-by-Step Solution:

Identify what the statement defines: a general maximum potential “a material” can withstand.Recognize that materials are characterized by dielectric strength (field), not a universal voltage.Note that breakdown voltage applies to a specific specimen dimension; doubling thickness doubles voltage withstand approximately.Therefore, the statement is not accurate as a general definition.


Verification / Alternative check:
Standards data sheets list dielectric strength for materials (e.g., 20 kV/mm for a film). To get breakdown voltage for a 0.5 mm sheet, you multiply: V_bd ≈ 20 kV/mm * 0.5 mm = 10 kV. Change thickness and the voltage changes, proving the distinction.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

  • Correct: Incorrect because it confuses a geometry-dependent rating (breakdown voltage) with a material property (dielectric strength).
  • Only true for gases / Only true above 1 kV: The distinction holds for solids, liquids, and gases across voltage ranges.
  • Depends only on temperature: Temperature affects limits but does not change the definition.


Common Pitfalls:
Using “breakdown voltage” as a universal material constant; ignoring thickness, edges, humidity, and contamination, which all impact actual breakdown voltage of a specimen.


Final Answer:
Incorrect

More Questions from Resistance and Power

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion