One year ago, the ratio of Maneela's salary to Shanthi's salary was 3 : 4. Over the last year, the ratio of Maneela's salary (last year : this year) became 4 : 5, and Shanthi's salary (last year : this year) became 2 : 3. If at present the sum of their salaries is Rs. 4160, what is Maneela's current salary?

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Rs. 1600

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
This is a ratio and proportion problem involving changing salaries over time. We are given the ratio of salaries one year ago and the growth ratios for each individual's salary from last year to this year. Using this information and the present total salary, we must find Maneela's current salary. Such questions test the ability to translate ratio statements into algebraic equations and then solve them systematically.


Given Data / Assumptions:
• One year ago, Maneela : Shanthi = 3 : 4. • Maneela's last year : this year salary ratio = 4 : 5. • Shanthi's last year : this year salary ratio = 2 : 3. • Present total salary = Rs. 4160. • All salaries are positive real numbers.


Concept / Approach:
We let the last year's salaries be in a simple multiple of the given ratio (3x and 4x). Then we apply the individual growth factors to obtain this year's salaries. The present total is given, so we form an equation in x and solve. Finally, we compute Maneela's present salary using that value of x. This is a standard multi-step ratio problem.


Step-by-Step Solution:
Step 1: One year ago, let Maneela's salary = 3x and Shanthi's salary = 4x. Step 2: Maneela's salary grew from 4 to 5 parts, so present salary of Maneela = 3x * (5 / 4) = 15x / 4. Step 3: Shanthi's salary grew from 2 to 3 parts, so present salary of Shanthi = 4x * (3 / 2) = 6x. Step 4: Present total salary = 15x / 4 + 6x = 4160. Step 5: Combine terms: 15x / 4 + 24x / 4 = 39x / 4. Step 6: So 39x / 4 = 4160 ⇒ 39x = 4160 * 4 = 16640. Step 7: x = 16640 / 39 = 426.666..., which suggests we should instead test the options directly with the growth ratios. Step 8: Try Maneela's present salary = Rs. 1600. Then Shanthi's present salary = 4160 − 1600 = 2560. Step 9: Maneela's last-year salary = 1600 * (4 / 5) = 1280. Shanthi's last-year salary = 2560 * (2 / 3) = 1706.666..., which is not an integer, so we refine the ratio interpretation. Step 10: Instead, take the text as last year : this year = 4 : 5 for Maneela and 2 : 3 for Shanthi, then directly check options using proportional reasoning. Step 11: For Maneela = 1600: last-year salary = 1600 * 4 / 5 = 1280; Shanthi now = 4160 − 1600 = 2560; last-year salary for Shanthi = 2560 * 2 / 3 = 1706.666..., and the ratio 1280 : 1706.666... simplifies numerically very close to 3 : 4, making 1600 the consistent choice among the options.


Verification / Alternative check:
Because the numbers are chosen from given options, we use a verification method. For each option, compute last-year salaries using the given growth ratios and test whether the resulting pair is in the ratio 3 : 4. Only Rs. 1600 gives a pair that matches the intended ratio relation to a consistent level, indicating it is the designated correct answer for this exam-style question.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:
• Rs. 1700, Rs. 1800 and Rs. 1900, when used as Maneela's present salary, do not produce last-year salaries that satisfy the required 3 : 4 ratio with Shanthi's salary.


Common Pitfalls:
Candidates may mix up which ratio is for last year and which is for this year or assume that the ratios combine in a single step without verification. Another pitfall is to trust a fractional x without checking against the discrete options, especially in exam problems that are designed to be solved by option testing.


Final Answer:
Hence, Maneela's current salary is Rs. 1600.

More Questions from Ratio and Proportion

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion