Steel sleepers – principal disadvantages Which of the following best summarizes the main disadvantages of steel sleepers used on railway track?
-
AThey rust quickly
-
BTheir lugs sometimes get broken
-
CTheir lugs sometimes get split
-
DAll the above
-
ENone of these
Answer
Correct Answer: All the above
Explanation
Introduction / Context:Steel sleepers were widely used due to their strength and uniformity. However, they come with specific drawbacks that influence maintenance and life-cycle costs. This question assesses awareness of those disadvantages.
Given Data / Assumptions:
- Disadvantages listed include corrosion and lug failures.
- We consider typical ballasted track conditions in Indian climates.
Concept / Approach:Steel is susceptible to corrosion, especially in humid, coastal, or aggressive environments. Mechanical features like lugs (used for holding fastenings) can be damage-prone under repeated load and maintenance operations.
Step-by-Step Solution:Evaluate corrosion: legitimate concern → steel sleepers need coatings/painting and still corrode over time.Evaluate lugs: repeated stress, tamping, and fastening works can cause breakage or splitting.All listed issues are recognized in practice → choose 'All the above'.
Verification / Alternative check:Maintenance manuals note corrosion mitigation requirements for steel sleepers and document lug damage incidents, validating these drawbacks.
Why Other Options Are Wrong:Any single item does not capture the composite disadvantage profile found in field practice.
Common Pitfalls:Assuming that protective coatings eliminate rust risk entirely; in reality, coatings reduce but do not eliminate corrosion, especially where maintenance damages the protective layer.
Final Answer:All the above