$M$ men agree to purchase a gift for ₹ $D$. If three men drop out how much more will each have to contribute towards the purchase of the gift?
Aptitude
Simplification
Difficulty: Medium
Choose an option
-
A$\frac{D}{M-3}$
-
B$\frac{MD}{3}$
-
C$\frac{M}{D-3}$
-
D$\frac{3D}{M^2 - 3M}$
Answer
Correct Answer: $\frac{3D}{M^2 - 3M}$
Explanation
### Concept & Strategy
This is an algebraic fraction problem. The "extra" contribution required is simply the difference between the new per-person cost and the original per-person cost.
$$ \text{Extra Contribution} = \text{New Share} - \text{Old Share} $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **Calculate the Original Share:** The total cost is $D$ and the original number of men is $M$.
* Original Share per man = $\frac{D}{M}$.
* **Calculate the New Share:** 3 men drop out, so the new number of men is $M - 3$. The total cost $D$ remains unchanged.
* New Share per man = $\frac{D}{M - 3}$.
* **Calculate the Difference:** Subtract the old share from the new share to find the increase.
* Increase = $\frac{D}{M - 3} - \frac{D}{M}$.
* **Simplify the Expression:** Find a common denominator, which is $M(M - 3)$.
* Multiply the first fraction by $\frac{M}{M}$: $\frac{DM}{M(M - 3)}$
* Multiply the second fraction by $\frac{M - 3}{M - 3}$: $\frac{D(M - 3)}{M(M - 3)}$
* Combine numerators: $\frac{DM - D(M - 3)}{M(M - 3)}$
* Expand the numerator: $DM - DM + 3D = 3D$.
* Expand the denominator: $M^2 - 3M$.
* Final expression: $\frac{3D}{M^2 - 3M}$.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
When variables confuse you under pressure, plug in simple numbers.
Let $D = 20$ (Total cost) and $M = 5$ (Total men).
Original share = $20 / 5 = \text{₹ } 4$.
If 3 drop out, new men = $2$. New share = $20 / 2 = \text{₹ } 10$.
Increase = $10 - 4 = \text{₹ } 6$.
Now, plug $D=20, M=5$ into the options and look for the one that equals 6:
(a) $20 / 2 = 10$ (Incorrect)
(b) $100 / 3 = 33.3$ (Incorrect)
(c) $5 / 17$ (Incorrect)
(d) $(3 \times 20) / (25 - 15) = 60 / 10 = 6$. (Match!)
### Common Pitfall
Subtracting the denominators incorrectly or selecting option (a), which is just the *new* total share, not the *increase* (the "how much more" asked in the question). Always pay attention to whether the question asks for the final state or the difference between states.
### Final Answer
**Therefore, the correct answer is $\frac{3D}{M^2 - 3M}$.**