Spurious liquor causes critical illness — identify immediate, just actions Statement: Many people became critically ill after consuming spurious liquor from a local shop. Courses of Action: I. Immediately close all liquor shops until stocks are tested for toxicity. II. Ask the shop owner to leave town and open elsewhere. III. Arrest the shop owner and try for criminal negligence.

Difficulty: Medium

Correct Answer: Only I and III follow

Explanation:


Introduction / Context:
Public safety is paramount in poisoning outbreaks. Responses should rapidly eliminate exposure, investigate, and hold culprits accountable—without resorting to extrajudicial or irrational measures.


Given Data / Assumptions:

  • Confirmed cluster of critical illness linked to a specific local liquor shop.
  • Spurious/toxic alcohol can contaminate wider supply chains.
  • Due process must be followed for enforcement.


Concept / Approach:

  • Remove suspected products from circulation pending testing.
  • Investigate and prosecute responsible parties using applicable criminal laws.
  • Avoid actions that are punitive without legal basis.


Step-by-Step Solution:

I follows: A temporary, area-wide suspension to test stocks prevents further harm. Scope can be risk-based, but the principle stands.II does not follow: Forcing the owner to leave town and sell elsewhere is unlawful and unsafe; it exports the risk.III follows: Probable criminal negligence or adulteration warrants arrest and trial under due process.


Verification / Alternative check:

Standard responses include seizures, lab testing, tracing supply chains, and prosecution—matching I and III.


Why Other Options Are Wrong:

I and II / II and III / All: Each includes the extralegal step II.III only: Omits urgent exposure control.


Common Pitfalls:

Acting punitively without legality; ignoring the immediate need to stop further poisonings.


Final Answer:

Only I and III follow

More Questions from Course of Action

Discussion & Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!
Join Discussion