The L.C.M. of three different numbers is 120. Which of the following cannot be their H.C.F.?
Aptitude
HCF and LCM
Difficulty: Easy
Choose an option
-
A8
-
B12
-
C24
-
D35
Answer
Correct Answer: 35
Explanation
### Concept & Logic
A fundamental property of numbers is that the Highest Common Factor (H.C.F.) of any set of numbers must always be a perfect divisor of their Lowest Common Multiple (L.C.M.). The L.C.M. must be completely divisible by the H.C.F. leaving no remainder.
$$ \frac{\text{L.C.M.}}{\text{H.C.F.}} = \text{Integer} $$
### Step-by-Step Solution
* **Given:** L.C.M. of the numbers = 120.
* To find which option *cannot* be the H.C.F., we must test each option to see if it perfectly divides 120. The one that leaves a remainder is the correct answer.
* **Test Option (a) 8:**
* $120 / 8 = 15$. (Perfect divisor, so it can be the H.C.F.)
* **Test Option (b) 12:**
* $120 / 12 = 10$. (Perfect divisor, so it can be the H.C.F.)
* **Test Option (c) 24:**
* $120 / 24 = 5$. (Perfect divisor, so it can be the H.C.F.)
* **Test Option (d) 35:**
* $120 / 35 \approx 3.42$. (Leaves a remainder).
* Because 35 does not divide 120 evenly, it is mathematically impossible for 35 to be the H.C.F. of these numbers.
### Exam Strategy & Shortcut
Use fast divisibility rules. The number 120 ends in a 0, meaning it is heavily factored by 2s, 3s, and 5s. You can quickly see that 8, 12, and 24 cleanly fit into it. Option (d), 35, breaks down to $7 \times 5$. Since 120 is not a multiple of 7, 35 can immediately be flagged as the non-divisor without full calculation.
### Common Pitfall
The most frequent mistake is speed-reading the question and missing the word "cannot". A student might see the 8, know it divides 120, and instantly select option (a) believing they solved it correctly. Always circle or underline negative constraints like "cannot" or "never" in exam prompts.
### Final Answer
**Therefore, the correct answer is 35.**